We've moved! Come join us at Watchdog Arena, where you'll continue to find the same quality articles that expose waste, fraud and abuse as well as examine policy issues at all levels of government.

Please visit our new home and follow us on social media: Facebook & Twitter

Get Involved!

Sign up as a Citizen Journalist and get involved in Information Activism.

Sign Up for Watchdog Updates!

New Jersey Transit Sues Insurers For $300 Million in Sandy Damages

On Oct. 1, New Jersey Transit sued a number of insurers for $300 million for damages incurred during Hurricane Sandy, saying its policies for windstorms covered up to $400 million. These insurers instead paid $100 million, citing the flood sublimit in said policies, which limits the payout to $100 million.

New Jersey Transit is the third-largest provider of rail, light rail and bus service in the country, and was hit hard by Hurricane Sandy. Its bus fleets and rail depots were flooded or otherwise damaged; damage to the Hoboken and Kearny railyards alone account for $120 million in damages. Overall, the agency says Hurricane Sandy incurred around $625 million in damages to them, and $342 million expected in federal relief funds, according to nj.com.

The defendants include Lloyds of London and “U.S. insurers Hudson Specialty Insurance Company, Maiden Specialty Insurance Company, RSUI Indemnity Company, Torus Specialty Insurance Company, and Westport Insurance Corporation”, according to nj.com. The suit, made to the Superior Court of New Jersey Law Division in Newark, says that the insurance against a named windstorm (like Sandy or other named storms) overrules the $100 million sublimit in the policies.

The policy sold to New Jersey Transit had four layers of coverage above the $500,000 per-occurrence deductible. The first layer paid $50 million, the second paid $50 million, the third paid $175 million and the fourth paid $125 million. Insurance Journal writes, “With the exception of the first layer provided by AIG’s Lexington Insurance Co., which is not a defendant in this lawsuit, multiple insurers including defendants are responsible for the coverage available in each layer, with each company assuming a certain percentage of each layers’ coverage limit.”

In the immediate aftermath of the storm, New Jersey Transit notified and continued to notify these defendants and other carriers of damages and repairs, and the ultimate cost of those repairs. In April 2013, however, the agency received notice that the defendants considered the damage from Sandy to be flooding, and therefore only eligible for the $100 million sublimit, which was $50 million in addition to the $50 million already paid by Lexington Insurance Co.

In December 2013, the insurers agreed to pay the $50 million within the policy’s second layer, bringing the total paid to New Jersey Transit to $100 million. New Jersey Transit has not received any of the remaining $300 million they claim they are owed, prompting the lawsuit filed on Oct. 1.

Featured image from Shutterstock

Brad Matthews

Brad Matthews is the Digital Content Coordinator intern for Watchdog Wire. Twitter is @bradmatthewsDC

More Posts - Twitter

Categories: Budget and Finance, Courts & Law, Must Read


  1. Red light cameras stopped in New Jersey, for now
  2. The policies that preserve New Jersey’s poverty
  3. Public policy consensus explains New Jersey’s rise in poverty
  4. Red light cameras to go dark in New Jersey
  5. Linden, NJ lobbies for continuation of red light camera program it needs for revenue


comments powered by Disqus