We've moved! Come join us at Watchdog Arena, where you'll continue to find the same quality articles that expose waste, fraud and abuse as well as examine policy issues at all levels of government.

Please visit our new home and follow us on social media: Facebook & Twitter

Get Involved!

Sign up as a Citizen Journalist and get involved in Information Activism.

Sign Up for Watchdog Updates!

Ohio Ranks 12th For Most Cronyist State

Does Ohio play fair? Or smart? When it comes to the number of dollars spent in subsidies, Ohio ranks the 12th cronyist.

The Mercatus Center recently illustrated how states rank in providing benefits to particular companies, rather than providing better opportunity for all companies.

Source: Mercatus Center

Source: Mercatus Center

Ohio’s neighboring states ranked 4th (Michigan), 5th (Kentucky), 7th (Indiana), and 11th (Pennsylvania) in the number of dollars spent on subsidies. Vernonique de Rugy used data from Subsidy Tracker 2.0, a project of Good Jobs First, to analyze how states compare.

De Rugy notes, “…established corporations, not small businesses or startups, are the overwhelming recipients of state benefits. Sometimes, subsidies are extended to subsidiary companies that appear small and unconnected at first glance.”

Good Jobs First has the breakdown of the top-ten recipients of subsidies in Ohio:

Source: Good Jobs First

Source: Good Jobs First

Do these subsidies really create jobs and economic growth though? “Targeted state subsidies to private businesses are often promoted as a “market-friendly” means to boost growth, jobs, and development. However, the empirical studies on state subsidies find that these programs have little to no effect in producing their intended goals,” according to de Rugy.

Subsidy Tracker 2.0 provides assistance in tracking subsidiary companies to their parent companies, providing a clearer picture of what companies receive the most benefits.

The State of Ohio has provided 7,201 subsidies totaling $4,135,021,231.00 (that’s $4.1 billion). These vary between grants, low-interest loans, and tax credits. Third Frontier, and Innovation Ohio are among the programs cited as sources for subsidies.

In addition to state agencies and initiatives, also contributing were the Cincinnati Ohio Economic Development, City of Cleveland Department of Economic Development, City of Toledo Department of Development, and Columbus Department of Development.

Nicole Kaeding and Chris Edwards of the Cato Institute commented in the 2014 Fiscal Report Card for governors that, “…many governors have supported narrow breaks to particular companies and industries, called ‘tax incentives.’ The Wall Street Journal called the increase in tax incentives a ‘tax-credit arms race.’”

Stephanie Kreuz

Stephanie is the editor of Watchdog Wire - Ohio. She is a graduate of Hillsdale College. You can contact her at Ohio@WatchdogWire.com for story ideas and ways to get involved with citizen journalism in the state of Ohio.

More Posts - Twitter

Categories: Government Transparency, Must Read, Policy
Tags: , , , , , ,


  1. Treasurer Mandel Opens State of Ohio Checkbook
  2. Cleveland-area mayor sues bloggers for $25,000 for criticism
  3. Conflicting claims about who killed bin Laden draw fire
  4. Ten Problems With How the Government Hires Employees
  5. Ohio Ranks 12th For Most Cronyist State


comments powered by Disqus